Overflow vs Grate Discharge Ball Mill: Which Fits Your Circuit?

MINERAL PROCESSING KNOWLEDGE · CRUSHING AND GRINDING

Overflow and grate discharge mills differ in pulp level, retention time and product, and that difference decides how a grinding circuit handles over-grinding.

Technical overview. Actual process selection depends on representative ore samples, mineralogy, testwork and site conditions.

A ball mill is normally chosen by shell diameter and length, and then specified almost as an afterthought by the way it empties. That afterthought shapes the whole grinding circuit. Two mills with identical shells can behave very differently at the discharge end: one holds a deep pool of pulp against the charge, the other drains it away as fast as the slots allow. The choice changes retention time, the amount of over-grinding, the stability of the product and the equipment needed after the mill.

Technical note: This is a principle-level comparison of discharge arrangements, not an engineering design, a mass balance or a performance guarantee. Grindability, target product size, circulating load and circuit configuration must be established by comminution testwork and reviewed by a qualified engineer before a mill is selected.

1. Two ways to empty a mill

In both arrangements the pulp leaves through the discharge trunnion. What differs is the barrier the pulp must cross to get there.

  • Overflow. The discharge end carries a trunnion opening with a raised lip, and the mill runs with the pulp level above the centre line of that opening. Pulp flows out simply because the charge is flooded. There are no slots to wear, nothing to block and no lifting mechanism to maintain, but the pool also cushions the charge: balls fall into slurry rather than onto bare rock, and every particle that reaches the discharge zone has had time to be ground again.
  • Grate discharge. The discharge end is fitted with slotted grates backed by lifters. Pulp drains through the slots at a low level, and the lifters carry it over the trunnion. Because the mill cannot flood, material leaves soon after it has been reduced, the charge is held back against the grates and the mill behaves more like a once-through device. The cost is a wear part: slots enlarge with use and must be inspected.

The practical effect is a trade between product fineness and throughput. The flooded mill holds material longer and therefore delivers a finer, more thoroughly ground product, at the risk of grinding some of it long past liberation. The drained mill passes tonnage quickly and protects coarse particles from being ground twice, which is why it is often paired with coarse liberation duties and high circulating loads handled outside the mill.

2. What the standard mill data shows

The published table describes shell, media and drive, and it makes the scale of the decision clear. Across the range the feed size is capped at 20 mm on the smallest shell and 25 mm on the rest, most models are quoted with a discharge size down to around 0.074 mm, and capacity runs from 0.65-2 t/h on Φ900×1800 to 45-208 t/h on Φ4000×5000. The same range of shells is applied to very different duties: concentrators for mineral liberation, the cement industry for clinker and blended materials, building materials such as limestone, quartz sand and fly ash, chemical raw material fine grinding, and metallurgy for fluxes and auxiliary materials.

ModelShell speed (r/min)Ball load (t)Feed size (mm)Discharge size (mm)Capacity (t/h)Motor power (kW)
Φ900×1800361.5≤200.075-0.890.65-218.5
Φ1200×2400363≤250.075-0.61.5-4.830
Φ1500×300032.47.5≤250.074-0.42-575
Φ1830×300025.411≤250.074-0.44-10130
Φ2100×300023.715≤250.074-0.46.5-36155
Φ2400×30002123≤250.074-0.47-50245
Φ2700×400020.740≤250.074-0.412-80380
Φ3200×45001865≤250.074-0.425-120630
Φ3600×45001790≤250.074-0.425-140850
Φ4000×500016.9121≤250.074-0.445-2081500

Two features of the table matter when the discharge arrangement is chosen. The first is that shell speed falls as the shell grows: 36 r/min on Φ900×1800 and 36 r/min on Φ1200×2400, but 32.4 r/min on Φ1500×3000 and 16.9 r/min on the largest mill, which carries 121 t of balls on a 1500 kW motor. A large mill works by size and media mass rather than by speed, and a deep pulp pool in a large shell is a great deal of slurry resting against the charge. The second is that the table gives no discharge arrangement at all. Every model here is quoted with a shell, a media charge, a feed limit, a product band and a drive; overflow or grate is a separate specification that has to be stated on the enquiry, because the same shell is offered in both forms.

3. Which discharge suits which circuit

The duty downstream usually decides. Where the mill grinds in closed circuit with a classifier and the target is a fine product, the longer retention of an overflow mill is an advantage, and the slow, thorough grinding action keeps the circulating load manageable. Where the mill takes a screened feed from a rod mill or a fine crusher and discharges to gravity concentration, the fast exit of a grate mill is preferable: it limits the slimes that gravity recovery cannot handle and it lifts tonnage through the same shell. Confirm four points before the enquiry goes out.

  • Product target and tolerance. A target set by liberation needs a stable top size; a target set purely by recovery tolerates slimes.
  • Circuit type. Closed circuit with a classifier behaves differently from open circuit, and so does the same mill in each case.
  • Feed preparation. A mill that accepts ground feed from a rod mill or a fine crusher sees a far narrower size distribution than one fed directly with crusher product.
  • Wear and access. Grates, lifters and trunnion liners are consumables, and the maintenance window has to exist before the arrangement is chosen.

Conclusion

Overflow and grate discharge are two answers to the same question: how long should a particle stay in the mill? The overflow arrangement keeps it there longer, giving a finer product and a forgiving, low-wear discharge at the cost of over-grinding and slimes. The grate arrangement releases it early, protecting throughput and coarse liberation at the cost of a wearing part that must be inspected. Because the arrangement is a separate specification rather than a different mill, the decision belongs to the circuit, not to the mill size.

How LiCheng Tech can help

Tell us your target product size, the feed you can deliver, the tonnage and the equipment downstream. We will compare overflow and grate configurations across the mill range, confirm feed and discharge limits against the duty and propose a grinding train that fits the circuit around it.

Explore the Ball Mill pages, look at the vibrating screen used to close the circuit, or send your project information.


Leave us a message

Tell us the material, the feed size and the capacity — we reply with a process proposal and an equipment list.

What Do You Need? *
Sent to our team — we reply within one working day

Contact us

WeChat:LiCheng_Tech007 info@lichengintl.com Get a quote